Catholic Singles Online Dating Guide

Catholic Single Praying

Being a Catholic single looking for love in today’s world can be a challenge. It’s hard enough to find someone that you mesh with well, are attracted to, and excites you without taking your faith into account.

The problem is that a lot of these people that seem like great matches end up not working out because they don’t share your Catholic belief system or they don’t view their faith with the same level of importance as you.

We’re guessing by the fact that you’re here with us that we don’t have to tell you that. You’re well aware that things can be frustrating and that’s why you’re here. The good news is that over the past few years several awesome Catholic online dating sites have emerged to help make things easier.

Catholic Singles

Choosing the Right Site

If you’re ready to get started and aren’t here for the tips and the help, we totally get it. To help you out, we’ve put together the top Catholic online dating sites that you’ll have the best experience at. We’ve reviewed these sites heavily and can confirm they are the best options available.

It’s also important to note that we never allow sites to pay us for a better recommendation or better review. These sites are truly the best options available and offer the most for Catholic singles in today’s dating world.

Mainstream vs. Dedicated

As you can see, we’ve only recommended Catholic-dedicated online dating sites. A big question that singles have is whether or not they should choose one of the best mainstream dating apps or one that caters specifically to their religious preference. The answer to this has to do with how important your faith is to you.

If you’re someone whose faith is not that important to you or is an afterthought a lot, then we recommend checking out a mainstream dating site. You’re going to have a much better time dating with people on mainstream sites who identify themselves as Catholic. If you’re someone whose faith is important to them, then you’re definitely going to want to choose a dedicated site, or at least have a laser-focused plan for the mainstream sites.

This does not mean you have to be someone who has all the answers and is “so Catholic” that you make the Pope look bad. No one is perfect, and there are plenty of people on these sites who are still figuring things out. As long as your faith is something that is important to you (regardless of where you are in your walk), then you’re going to have a much better dating experience with one of these sites.

More Than One Site?

Another question Catholic singles ask a lot is whether or not they should join one site or join multiple ones. The answer to this from our experience is that you should check out a couple of sites but ultimately only join one.

The apps we’ve recommended give you free trials where you can check out the matches and how the site is set up. This costs you nothing except for a few minutes of your time. What we recommend is taking advantage of these free trials and finding the site that looks best to you and then joining that one.

The reason we don’t recommend joining multiple dating sites at once is that you may end up getting overloaded with matches. This might sound like something awesome, but you can end up not dedicating enough time or effort to your matches that deserve it. Remember, you’re not here looking for hundreds of dates if you don’t have to. You’re looking for someone special to hopefully fall in love with and get married to. That only takes one person to fulfill that role.

If you’re ready to use a free trial, click the links at the top of this page and you’ll see a button to receive your free trial automatically. These trials are great because they allow you to see what each dating site has to offer without having to join as a member right away.

Know Where You Stand on the Issues

When you choose to put your faith at the foreground of your dating, it’s important that you know where you stand on some of the bigger issues. Within Catholicism, there are a lot of different teachings that people will differ on what they think is correct. These issues might be small, and might be something that won’t affect a relationship much at all. Some of these issues, though, are integral to your faith and should be treated as deal breakers.

If you’re a Catholic single, you need to take some time to figure out where you stand on these issues. If you’re wishy-washy on your views, it’s going to make dating difficult. You might find someone who you like, but they don’t view their faith exactly the same way you do. This can lead to heartache and issues further down the road as you get to know each other more.

The best advice we can give you is to take the online dating process seriously and spend some time self-reflecting before you get started. Look at the issues that are important to you and your faith and decide where you stand on them. Figure out which of these issues would be a deal breaker and which you would be willing work with.

Not sure where to start? Take a look at the next section we have on understanding the faith-based questions. A good Catholic dating site is going to bring these issues to the foreground and help to match you with other singles who share the same views as you.

Understanding the Faith-Based Questions

When you join a Catholic online dating site, you’re going to be answering a lot of questions about you, your life, and most importantly your religious faith. Sometimes these questions aren’t going to be ones that you can answer in a matter of seconds.

To help you out, we’ve pulled some of the most popular faith-based questions you’ll run into as a Catholic single dating online. It’s important to look at these to know where you stand and to know what you’re looking for. Sometimes you will get people on religious sites who aren’t religious, which can work or not, depending on where you stand.

Catholic Singles Question 1

A question that we see on some sites is whether or not you are free to marry within the Catholic Church. This question isn’t asked everywhere, but we have certainly seen it more than once.

Cathlic Singles Question 2

Some Catholic dating sites will ask singles what type of schooling they had growing up. While your schooling doesn’t define you, it may have a big impact on who you are or how your faith plays into your life. It also may have an effect on how you might want to raise your kids if you do choose to have any.

Catholic Singles Question 3

This is a fairly straightforward question that asks how often you attend Mass. We highly recommend that you answer this question (and all of them) honestly. No one is going to judge you if you don’t attend Mass as often as you’d like.

Cathlic Singles Question 4

This is a great question for singles that we see on a few dating sites. It helps potential matches to see some more about your history and what has helped to shape you into the person you are today.

Catholic Singles Question 5

This is a preference question that if fairly popular on Catholic dating sites. You can obviously understand why this might be an important question when trying to find potential dates and matches.

Catholic Singles Question 6

This question is one of the most important and should play a big role in helping you have success. You’ll want to be honest and let people know how important your faith is in your life.

Catholic Singles Question 7

The Catholic Church sometimes differs on it’s teaching on the Eucharist. This will be something that you may need to spend some time figuring out where you stand. Here’s a great guide on the subject in case you need some more information to prepare for this question.

Catholic Singles Question 8

Again, this is a Catholic issue that you’ll need to decide for yourself where you stand. To help you out, here’s a great article about the topic of contraception.

Catholic Singles Question 9

Here is some information to help you prepare for the possibility of this question being asked by the dating site or being brought up by a potential match.

Catholic Singles Question 10

This is another issue that you’ll need to decide where you stand. While you won’t see this asked often at online dating sites, we have seen it before. Here’s some information on Papal Infallibility to help you out.

Catholic Singles Question 11

This is a question that has become much more pressing in today’s world. Out of all of the questions on this list, this is the one that as a Catholic single in today’s world you may run into the most.

Catholic Singles Question 12

Here’s some information on Immaculate Conception to help you out.

Catholic Singles Question 13

The last question we have for you today to look at is where you stand on the teaching of the Holy Orders. Here’s some information from the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops on Holy Orders.

While these are certainly not all the questions that might come up, these are the main ones that we’ve seen at several Catholic dating sites. Should you expect to see all of these questions? Certainly not.

Some sites like to ask these to help with their matching algorithm and some sites like to leave it up to you to dig into if you want. You don’t have to wait until you have answers on all of these to get started. We just wanted to do our best to give you a head start and a heads up.

Getting Started the Right Way

At this point, you have all of the pieces that you need to have a successful online dating experience as a Catholic Single. Here’s our advice to put it all together. First, take your time. There is no rush to find the love of your life in the next five minutes. You can take your time and know that the person God made for you is out there and you will find them.

Make sure you take the time to know where you stand on the religious issues and don’t waiver on the ones that are deal breakers for you. Once you’re set on those, click on a few of the sites we recommended at the top of the page. Each has a full review of the site as well as a button for a completely free trial. Take advantage of this trial and find the site that is best for you.

When you find it, join the site and get to searching! If you’re brand new to online dating, we do recommend taking a minute and reading our beginner’s guide to online dating.

Photo of author

Author: Healthy Framework Team

The Healthy Framework team has a combined 50+ years of experience in the online dating industry. Collectively, the team has reviewed over 300 dating apps and is known as one of the leaders in the relationship advice and information space. The team's work has been featured on Zoosk, Tinder, The Economist, People Magazine, Parade, Women's Health, Her Campus, Fox, and more.