We Tested the 4 Best Serious Relationship Dating Apps

Fact Checked by: Rychel Johnson, M.S., LCPC

Disclosure: We may earn a small commission from some links on this page. This never affects our rankings or recommendations. You may check out our full Monetization Transparency Policy here.

Tired of all the games? Tired of dating apps and sites that are filled with flaky people just looking for hookups? Yea, we don’t blame you. Unfortunately, that’s what you can expect when you use the wrong types of sites. But there is hope! There are dating apps built for serious relationships.

These dating apps are designed to attract singles looking for something more meaningful. They help you to cut through the noise, get real results, and find other singles looking for lasting love.

The leader for serious relationships is still eharmony.

eharmony for serious relationships screenshot

eharmony is the crown jewel when it comes to the best dating apps for relationships. The site prides itself on attracting singles that are looking for something special—which is a fancy way of saying commitment. You’ll find very few, if any, people just trying to find something casual. What’s funny is that in other lists of the best dating apps, we say that one of the biggest drawbacks of eharmony is that it’s no good for casual dating. So, you can imagine how for this list, it makes it even more of a perfect fit.

Additionally, the app has an in-depth matching questionnaire that all new members have to take when signing up. While this takes a few minutes to complete, it becomes pretty clear fast that eharmony cares about relationships and matching people for success.

If you’re looking for a serious relationship, eharmony is what you’re looking for.

  • 2 million+ people have found relationships on the app
  • iOS Store Rating – 4.0/5.0
  • 5 million+ Google Play Installs

Less than 2 years old, Higher Bond has surged for serious relationships.

Higher Bond is a top-notch option for Christian singles looking for a serious relationship. The concept is built around “Real Christian Dating”, which is a fancy way of saying that it’s designed for Christians who not only take their faith seriously, but take their relationships serious too. In a niche that is often underserved, Higher Bond is looking to not only be Christian in name, but in practice as well.

The way the app achieves this is through a whole host of features. These include manual account approvals, an in-depth faith-focused matching questionnaire, limits on how many matches you can see and message daily, and an overall approach built around the principles of faith. It’s one of the reasons that Higher Bond also tops our list of the best Christian singles dating apps.

  • In-depth matching questionnaire
  • Focused on more serious Christian singles
  • Free 3-month membership if you sign up now

High performers looking for love should consider The League

The league for serious relationships screenshot

The League is another serious dating app that falls into the interesting category. Why? Exclusivity. Compared with all of the other serious options on this list, it’s by and far the most exclusive option. This, of course, comes with some big pros and cons to be aware of.

First, here’s what we mean when we say exclusivity. The app requires you to get on a waiting list to join, requires you to be approved and voted in through a strict process, and not every one gets in. In fact, data we’ve found shows its about 1 in 5 who actually make it in.

While this sounds annoying, what it does it preserves quality across the app. If you’re looking for a serious relationship and the quality of your partner is number one on your list (and you’re okay with that being a bit pretentious), The League is certainly worth checking out. But, if you don’t like the idea of some people not being allowed in, it might not be the right option for you.

  • A better option in major cities in the US
  • High quality singles because of exclusivity features
  • High tech algorithm and user interface

Long-lasting relationships for Catholics may be found at CM

Catholic Match for serious relationships screenshot

While smaller than some of the other options on this list, Catholic Match is designed to serve a distinct niche—building serious Catholic relationships. And as one of the leading Catholic dating app options, the app does quite well at this. Here’s a few reasons why.

First, user-friendliness is high. It’s easy to sign up, can be used from multiple platforms (desktop, iOS, Android), and is easy to figure out how to match and message. Second, Catholic Match has a lot of partnerships with Catholic leaders and organizations, which shows its commitment to the more serious aspects of Catholic Dating. Third, the app allows you to share where you stand on different Catholic doctrine issues, so you can find someone that better fits with your belief system. This is paramount to a serious faith based relationship.

Again, Catholic Match is smaller than the other apps on this list of serious dating apps, but it hits a homerun when it comes to serious Catholic dating.

  • Backed by Catholic leaders
  • #1 in Catholic dating
  • Decades of experience in the industry

What Makes a Dating App Great for Serious Relationships?

When making our list of the top dating apps for serious relationships we noticed a few trends that successful apps seem to share. If you’re looking for a dating app to lead to something lasting here are five things you’ll want to make sure they have:

Marketing Designed to Attract Relationship-Minded Singles

The best dating apps for serious relationships don’t accidentally become higher-quality options. Generally, it’s a result of highly-targeted marketing campaigns aimed at finding singles looking for something a little more serious. Trust us; there is a reason that people looking for a hookup stay far away from eharmony. It’s because their outreach team focuses on finding commitment-minded singles.

Search Filters Based on What You’re Looking For

Inevitably, there are going to be people on every dating app who are looking for different things. This is okay. However, we require that a dating app offer ways to sort people based on wants and needs in order to earn a spot on our recommended list. So, that way, you can remove anyone that is just looking for something casual and only leave the people looking for relationships.

Affordable Pricing

Price is certainly a factor to consider when assessing options for more serious relationships. For us, it’s two-fold. First, we’re not fans of completely free apps. We love free trials, but we think completely free apps just don’t have enough people serious about finding love.

Second, we look at costs based on value. Again, we’re not always looking for the least expensive app. What we want to find is a dating app that offers great value for what you pay.

Great Customer Service

Ideally, you’ll be able to use your serious dating apps without any hiccups whatsoever. However, if you ever need help with something, it’s important that there is great customer service ready and willing to help. All of the dating apps for more serious relationships recommended here have top-quality customer service teams ready to go to work for you.

Mobile Compatibility

What good is a mobile app if it doesn’t work on all of the major operating systems? It’s no good! The top dating apps for serious relationships work with Google devices, Androids, and iPhone (iOS) systems. So, no matter what type of phone you have, you should have no problems getting it loaded up on your phone or tablet.

Apps NOT for Serious Relationships

While there’s nothing inherently wrong with casual dating if that’s what you were looking for you probably wouldn’t be on this page. Here are some dating apps you should avoid if you’re looking for a serious relationship online:

Tinder Logo

Tinder

Flirt logo

Flirt.com

Friend Finder Dating Logo

FriendFinder

These apps have far less logic behind matchmaking and instead focus strictly on initial attraction. Despite what you make have heard anywhere else, if you’re looking for a serious dating app none of these options will meet your needs!

Singles using these are primarily looking for flings, hookups, and casual dating.
Photo of author

Author: Matt Seymour, MSF

Matthew J. Seymour is a dating industry expert with over a decade of experience coaching singles, reviewing dating apps, and analyzing trends within the industry. Matt is a published author with his most recent work “Get More Dates: How to Master Online Dating Apps” that hit shelves in 2023. With a Masters of Science in Finance (MSF) degree from the University of Florida and extensive knowledge of the innerworkings of the online dating industry, Matt frequently serves in an advisory role to some of the largest dating apps on the market. In Matt’s current role with Healthy Framework, he leads the interview team that regularly interviews key dating industry leaders, and leverages his financial knowledge and dating app experience to review and share what singles need to know to get the most out of dating online.