Christian Mingle vs Christian Café

Christian Mingle and Christian Café are two well-known online dating sites that both cater to Christian singles looking for a long-term relationship leading to marriage. But which of these two options is best for you? Does it really matter which site you choose? The upfront spoiler is that it does matter as each dating site offers a different online dating experience that’s going to be critical to helping you find that special someone.

So, how do you decide the winner of the Christian Mingle vs. Christian Café battle? That’s where we come in!

In this article, we’ll break down all of the specifics that you want to know before choosing which site you’d like to sign up with. There are some differences with Christian Mingle vs Christian Café to note, primarily in how the sites work and what kind of information is presented on member profiles.

Let’s dive into it!

The Easiest Way to Decide a Winner

Before we share our thoughts, we want to point something interesting out. The single best way to decide the winner of the Christian Café vs. Christian Mingle debate is to check things out for yourself. What we recommend is to take a few minutes and check out each site for yourself.

Isn’t that going to be expensive? Nope! We’ve included some free trial links below that you can use to start your comparison search.

Christian Mingle Logo

Key Differences Between Christian Mingle and Christian Café

  • Christian Mingle has shorter and more streamlined profiles, whereas Christian Cafe’s profiles go more in-depth. Neither is “better,” it just depends on whether you prefer to know more about someone before you message them or you like to learn more as you chat with them.
  • Christian Café’s free trial is limited to 10 days, but it gives you full access to all features, including messaging. Christian Mingle’s free trial has no expiration date on it, but there are limitations to what you’re able to do. Both trials are robust enough to give you a clear picture of whether or not it’s worth upgrading to a premium membership or not.
  • The interface of Christian Café is a bit outdated. Christian Mingle does have a very up to date interface that’s very user friendly.
  • Both dating sites do a wonderful job of connecting single Christians with a focus on faith.
  • While you’re only looking for that one special person, Christian Mingle does boast a larger pool of single Christians (>15 million)

Cost Difference of Christian Café vs. Christian Mingle

Sometimes budget is (and should be) an important part of deciding which online dating app is best for you. When it comes to Christian Café vs. Christian Mingle, there’s a lot to breakdown with pricing.

If you look at things strictly from a “which site costs more” standpoint, Christian Café is less expensive. When you compare both sites against the industry, both fall below the average pricing, meaning they’re on the less expensive side.

Where it really starts to get interesting is when you start comparing price to value and features. It’s easy to think the least expensive site is the best, but the reality is that as long as it fits in the budget, the site that offers the best chances of finding that special mate is going to be the best. As you’ll see in our next section, Christian Mingle does come with more features, more members, and an updated interface, which may very well justify the slightly higher price.

Christian Mingle vs Christian Café Feature Comparison

Number of Members

Christian Mingle and Christian Café both have large singles communities located primarily across the U.S. and Canada. Christian Café boasts about their thousands of happy couples, vs. Christian Mingle who stakes claim as the largest Christian singles community at 15 million members. Christian Café doesn’t reference how many total accounts they have on their site, but based on our research it looks to be a slightly smaller community.

Swipe-Style Features

If you’re someone who likes the swipe-style dating (where you see a parade of people and swipe whether you like them or not looking for mutual matches), Christian Mingle is going to take the cake here. The site offers a feature called the LookBook that is, well, just that—a swipe-style way to meet Christian singles. As of our last Christian Café review, we didn’t see any similar functionality. Not a huge deal for many, but just something to be aware of.

Christian Owned

Something that may or may not be important to you is who is running the ship at each of these dating app options. Christian Café is a solo dating site exclusively run by Christians. Christian Mingle, on the other hand, is run by Spark Networks, who runs a whole portfolio of other online dating sites in and out of the religious niche. This certainly does not mean that the singles you meet on Christian Mingle will be any less Christian, but it’s a difference for you to consider.

User Interface

Both dating app options are fairly easy to use with easy to find menus that link to the things that you need. We did find, though, that Christian Mingle’s user interface was probably the easiest to use in the industry (not just in the Christian Café vs. Christian Mingle matchup). It’s very updated and works great on mobile. Christian Café’s website does feel a bit older, but still works reliably and gets the job done.

Dedicated Mobile Apps

If you’re someone who really wants a dedicated mobile app, Christian Mingle wins out in that department. The site can be accessed from a mobile-responsive website, a dedicated Android app, or a dedicated iOS app. Christian Café currently doesn’t offer an app, but the site is mobile-responsive, which means you can use it from your phone or tablet without any problems through the browser. Again, neither of these is inherently better than the other, just a matter of personal preference.

The Bottom Line

As you can see, both of these dating apps and sites are great options for Christian singles. The answer to which is better depends solely on your preferences. Again, the best way for you to make a decision is to try out each site for yourself through the free trial links we provided above. The bottom line? Both of these sites easily make our list of the best Christian dating sites on the market.

Matt Seymour

Written By: Matthew J. Seymour, MSF

Matthew J. Seymour is a dating industry expert with over a decade of experience coaching singles, reviewing dating apps, and analyzing trends within the industry. Matt is a published author with his most recent work “Get More Dates: How to Master Online Dating Apps” that hit shelves in 2023. With a Masters of Science in Finance (MSF) degree from the University of Florida and extensive knowledge of the innerworkings of the online dating industry, Matt frequently serves in an advisory role to some of the largest dating apps on the market. In Matt’s current role with Healthy Framework, he leads the interview team that regularly interviews key dating industry leaders, and leverages his financial knowledge and dating app experience to review and share what singles need to know to get the most out of dating online.